← All Articles

A severe storm can cause significant damage to your home's roof — but the aftermath doesn't have to be overwhelming. This comprehensive guide walks you through every step of the process, from your first actions after the storm to securing competitive bids from vetted contractors. With over a decade of roofing industry experience, I've helped hundreds of homeowners navigate this exact situation. You'll learn what insurance companies expect, how to document damage properly, and how to get the best repair options available.

1

Assess Immediate Safety Concerns

Your safety comes first. After a storm, take a moment to check for any immediate hazards before inspecting your roof.

  • Check for fallen trees or power lines on your roof or against your home. Do not attempt to remove these yourself — call your utility company immediately.
  • Look for water damage inside your home. Check your attic, ceilings, and walls for signs of water intrusion or leaks.
  • Stay off the roof unless you're experienced at working at heights. Wet or damaged roofing materials are extremely slippery and dangerous.
  • Watch for fallen debris in your yard and keep children and pets away from the area.

If you see structural damage, sagging sections, or signs of a potential collapse, evacuate the area and call emergency services.

2

Document All Visible Damage Thoroughly

Before your insurance adjuster arrives, document everything. This evidence is crucial for your claim.

  • Take photos and videos of all visible damage from multiple angles. Include wide shots showing the overall condition of your roof and close-ups of specific damage.
  • Photograph the interior damage too. Water stains on ceilings, wet insulation, and damaged drywall all strengthen your claim.
  • Note the date and time the photos were taken. Most smartphones automatically timestamp photos.
  • Create a written inventory describing all damage: broken shingles, missing sections, dents, punctures, or granule loss.
  • Save receipts and documentation of any temporary repairs you make to prevent further water damage.
Pro tip: Store copies of all photos and documents in cloud storage (Google Drive, Dropbox, iCloud) so you have them accessible from anywhere, even if something happens to your phone or computer.
3

Take Temporary Protective Measures

If water is entering your home, take action immediately to prevent further damage. Document these temporary repairs for your insurance claim.

  • Use tarps or plastic sheeting to cover damaged areas and prevent water intrusion. Secure them tightly to prevent them from blowing off.
  • Place buckets under leaks and mop up standing water to prevent mold growth.
  • Increase ventilation by opening windows (if weather permits) or running fans to help dry out damp areas.
  • Contact professional water restoration companies if there's significant water damage inside your home. This may be covered by your homeowners insurance.

Keep all receipts for these temporary repairs — they're often reimbursable as part of your claim.

Ready to Get Your Roof Repaired?

After you've filed your insurance claim, OtterQuote connects you with vetted contractors who submit competitive bids for your project — completely free.

Learn How It Works
4

File Your Insurance Claim Promptly

Contact your homeowners insurance company as soon as possible. Most policies require you to report damage promptly.

  • Call your insurance agent or company immediately. Have your policy number ready and describe the damage clearly.
  • Request an insurance adjuster to visit your home. This inspection is a key part of the claims process.
  • Provide your documentation. Share the photos and written inventory you created earlier.
  • Get a claim number and reference information. You'll need this for all future correspondence.
  • Understand your deductible. This is the amount you'll pay before insurance covers the rest. Ask your adjuster to explain how your deductible applies.
Important: Many insurance policies require you to mitigate further damage. This means taking reasonable steps (like tarping) to prevent additional water intrusion. Your insurance company expects this and won't penalize you for it.
5

Schedule the Insurance Adjuster Inspection

The insurance adjuster's visit is critical. Prepare your home and have documentation ready.

  • Be present during the inspection. Walk with the adjuster and point out all damage you've documented. Ask questions if you don't understand their assessment.
  • Provide access to affected areas. This includes your attic, interior ceilings, and any areas with water damage.
  • Ask for a detailed written estimate. This should list all damage found and estimated repair costs.
  • Request clarity on coverage. Ask which damages are covered, which are not, and why.
  • Get everything in writing. Don't rely on verbal explanations — ensure all findings and decisions are documented.

If you disagree with the adjuster's assessment, you have the right to request a re-inspection or hire an independent adjuster (often called a "public adjuster").

6

Review Your Insurance Estimate and Receive Approval

After the inspection, your insurance company will provide an estimate. Review it carefully before proceeding.

  • Check the estimate against your documentation. Verify that all damage you photographed is included.
  • Confirm the coverage amount. Understand what the insurance company is offering to pay after your deductible.
  • Ask about depreciation. Some policies deduct for the age of your roof (though many states now restrict this).
  • Get written approval from your insurance company before hiring a contractor. This is essential for your peace of mind.

Once approved, you're ready to move forward with repairs. This is where getting competitive bids becomes invaluable.

Get Competing Contractor Bids — Free

With your insurance claim approved, post your project on OtterQuote. Vetted contractors will submit competitive bids, and you choose the best one — all without paying anything upfront.

See How OtterQuote Works
7

Research and Vet Qualified Contractors

Not all roofers are created equal. Take time to find qualified, insured, and reputable contractors.

  • Verify licensure and insurance. Ask contractors for proof of active roofing licenses and current liability insurance. Never hire unlicensed workers.
  • Check references and reviews. Read online reviews, ask for references from recent projects, and follow up with those references.
  • Get multiple bids. Never hire the first contractor you contact. Competitive bids protect your interests and ensure fair pricing.
  • Look for storm damage experience. Contractors who regularly handle insurance claims understand the process and work efficiently.
  • Verify warranty offerings. Ask about material warranties and workmanship guarantees. Most reputable contractors offer both.

This is where OtterQuote simplifies the process. Our platform connects you with pre-vetted contractors who understand insurance claims and submit competitive bids automatically.

8

Compare Bids and Choose Your Contractor

Now that you have multiple bids, evaluate them carefully before making your decision.

  • Don't choose based on price alone. The cheapest bid isn't always the best value. Consider the contractor's reputation, experience, and warranty.
  • Compare material specifications. Are contractors using the same quality of materials? Different shingles and components can affect longevity and performance.
  • Check timeline and availability. When can they start? How long will the project take? Storm damage often creates scheduling backlog.
  • Review the scope of work. Ensure each bid includes everything your insurance estimate covers. Ask about any gaps.
  • Ask about payment terms. Most contractors require a deposit but should align with your insurance payment schedule.
Insider tip: If multiple bids are significantly higher than your insurance estimate, ask contractors why. They may see additional damage not visible to the adjuster, or they may use premium materials. Either way, get clarification.
9

Sign the Contract and Coordinate with Your Insurance Company

Once you've chosen your contractor, formalize the agreement and ensure your insurance company approves it.

  • Review the contract thoroughly. It should specify all work to be performed, materials used, timeline, total cost, and warranty terms.
  • Ensure insurance-related language is included. The contract should address how the insurance payment will be applied and any deductible responsibilities.
  • Notify your insurance company of the contractor you've selected. Some insurance companies prefer to work directly with the contractor regarding payment.
  • Understand payment schedule. Typically: initial deposit, progress payment, final payment upon completion. Never pay in full upfront.
  • Verify the contractor obtains permits if required by your municipality. They should handle this as part of the contract.

This is the final step before work begins. Take your time and ensure everything is clear before signing.

10

Oversee the Work and Ensure Quality

Once repairs begin, stay involved to ensure quality work and proper completion.

  • Be available for progress inspections. Check in regularly to see how the work is progressing.
  • Verify materials match the contract. Ensure the shingles, flashing, and other materials match what was agreed upon.
  • Request before-and-after photos. A professional contractor will document their work throughout the project.
  • Don't make final payment until work is complete and you've verified all items on the contract are finished.
  • Request a final inspection from your insurance company (if required). Some insurers inspect completed work before releasing final payment.

Quality contractors welcome this oversight because they know their work speaks for itself.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long do I have to file an insurance claim after storm damage?

Most homeowners insurance policies require you to report damage promptly, typically within 30 days. However, don't wait this long — file immediately after the storm. The sooner you file, the sooner the claims process begins, and the faster you can get repairs started. Delayed claims may face scrutiny from your insurance company about whether new damage occurred between the storm and the claim filing.

What if my contractor's bid is higher than the insurance estimate?

This happens frequently. Contractors may discover additional damage not visible to the insurance adjuster, use higher-quality materials, or include additional work recommended for your specific roof. Ask your contractor to explain the difference in writing. If legitimate additional work is needed, you may negotiate with your insurance company for a supplemental claim. Never pay out-of-pocket for work that should have been covered — request a re-inspection from your insurance company first.

Do I have to use a specific contractor my insurance company recommends?

No. Your insurance company cannot require you to use a specific contractor. You have the right to choose any licensed, insured contractor. Some insurance companies may steer you toward preferred vendors (often offering faster claims processing), but this is optional. You should always choose a contractor based on reputation, qualifications, and competitive bidding — not insurance company preference alone.

What happens if the contractor and insurance company disagree on the scope of work?

This can happen, especially if the contractor identifies additional damage. Most insurance policies have an "appraisal clause" that allows you to request an independent evaluation if you and the insurance company can't agree. An appraiser (hired jointly by you and your insurer) reviews the dispute and makes a binding decision. Alternatively, some contractors will document additional issues and request a supplemental inspection from your insurance company. Always communicate with both parties to resolve disputes amicably.

Will my homeowners insurance rates increase after filing a roof damage claim?

This varies by insurance company and state. In many cases, claims for natural disasters like storms are treated more favorably than other claim types. Some insurance companies don't raise rates for weather-related claims at all. Check with your insurance agent before filing if you're concerned about rate increases. That said, a small rate increase is often better than absorbing a large repair bill yourself. Focus on getting proper coverage for your home's safety and value.

How can I ensure I get the best price for roof repairs?

The best way is to get competitive bids from multiple qualified contractors. OtterQuote simplifies this process — post your project once your insurance claim is approved, and vetted contractors submit bids automatically. You'll compare pricing, materials, warranties, and timelines all in one place. This competitive environment naturally drives fair pricing while ensuring you work with qualified, insured professionals.

Ready to Move Forward?

Once your insurance claim is approved, let OtterQuote connect you with vetted contractors. Get competitive bids, compare options, and choose the best fit — all without paying anything upfront. You focus on recovery; we handle the rest.

Get Started Today