This guide walks you through every step of selecting a qualified contractor for insurance repair work: what credentials to verify, what red flags to recognize before you're committed, which questions will reveal how a contractor actually operates, and how to read a contract before you sign it.
After your property is damaged — whether from a windstorm, hail, fire, or water — the pressure to get it fixed quickly is real. Contractors know this, and not all of them operate honestly. Choosing the wrong one can mean subpar repairs, out-of-pocket costs your insurer won't cover, legal problems from an assignment of benefits you didn't fully understand, or simply work that fails inspection.
If you've already filed your claim, you may also find our guide on how to file a property damage insurance claim useful for understanding where contractor selection fits in the overall process.
1. What Credentials to Check
Before you spend any time talking scope or price with a contractor, confirm they have the credentials the job requires. Have the contractor email you the documents before you meet, then confirm each one is accurate before you sign a contract.
The pre-meeting email
Call the contractor's main office to set the appointment. Ask for the name, email address and phone number of the sales rep who will come to your home. Then email that rep directly and ask for the documents. The email can be as simple as this:
Dear [Name],
Before our meeting on [date], please send me the following so I can review them:
- A copy of every state and local license that applies to work at my address;
- A certificate of insurance showing your general liability and workers' compensation coverage, with me listed as the certificate holder;
- A copy of any bond you have filed with a state or local government agency; and
- A blank copy of your standard contract.
Thank you,
[Your name]
A professional, well-organized contractor can send these in minutes. A delay is a red flag. It may mean the contractor is new to the industry and hasn't been asked before, that they're disorganized and don't keep these documents on hand, or that they don't have them at all, possibly because of financial trouble. This email alone can tell you more about the company and the sales rep than a meeting at your kitchen table ever will. If the rep can't get you standard documents quickly and easily now, things will only get harder as the job moves along.
What each document should show
Contractor's license
Licensing rules for roofing, general contracting, electrical, plumbing, HVAC and other trades differ from state to state, and in some places the city or county sets them. The license you receive should name the same business that appears on the estimate, and the license type should match your job. If the contractor says they're "exempt" from licensing, don't take their word for it. Confirm the exemption with the office that would issue the license (Section 2).
General liability insurance
This covers damage the contractor causes to your property while working. Without it, if a crew member drops a ladder through your skylight or causes a leak that ruins your flooring, you may be left trying to recover the cost from the contractor yourself. Look at the coverage limit on the certificate. For a large or complex project, it's reasonable to ask for higher limits. The National Roofing Contractors Association advises asking for copies of the contractor's liability insurance coverage and workers' compensation certificates.
Workers' compensation insurance
This covers the contractor's employees if they're hurt on the job. The rules on who must carry it differ by state. The certificate should show a separate workers' compensation policy, not just general liability. A contractor who says they don't need it (for example, a sole proprietor with no employees) should be able to show you why.
Bonds
Some states and cities require contractors to file a license or permit bond. If a bond applies, the copy you receive should name the contractor's business, the agency it was filed with, and the surety company that issued it.
Standard contract
Read it before the meeting, not at the kitchen table. Section 6 covers the terms to refuse.
Business registration
You don't need to ask for this one; you can look it up yourself (Section 2). If the contractor is an LLC or corporation, it should be active in your state's business registry. A sole proprietor may not appear there, so ask what name the business is licensed under.
- License confirmed active with the office that issues it
- Certificate of insurance confirmed with the insurer (general liability and workers' comp)
- Any bond confirmed with the agency or surety
- Business name the same on the license, the certificate, the estimate and the contract
- A physical business address (not a PO box or personal address)
2. Confirming the Documents Are Real
Documents can be faked. A license can be expired, and a certificate of insurance can be forged or issued on a policy that has since been cancelled. Here are the quickest ways to confirm what the contractor sent you.
Confirm the license (about 2 minutes)
Go straight to the website of the office that issued it: your state's contractor licensing board, or your city or county building department. Don't rely on a search result that might lead to a third-party listing. Search by license number (most accurate) or business name, and check that:
- The status is "active" or "current," not expired, suspended or revoked
- The license type matches the trade
- The name matches the estimate and contract
- The license covers your city or county (some licenses are local, not statewide)
Confirm the insurance (about 5 minutes)
Call the insurance company named on the certificate. Use the number on the insurer's official website, not the one printed on the document. Ask them to confirm the policy is active for the contractor's business. This is the only way to know the certificate wasn't fabricated or issued on a policy that was later cancelled. While you're on the phone:
- Check the expiration dates. The policy must be active the day work starts and throughout the job. If it expires mid-project, ask for a renewed certificate before work continues.
- Check that workers' compensation shows a policy number, not "not applicable," unless you've confirmed with your state's workers' compensation agency that the contractor is exempt.
Confirm any bond (about 2 minutes)
Many licensing boards show the bond on the contractor's license record. If yours doesn't, call the surety company named on the bond, again using the number from its own website, and confirm the bond is active.
Confirm the business registration (about 1 minute)
Search your state's business registry (in many states the secretary of state runs it) for the business name and confirm it's active.
3. Red Flags to Watch For
Unscrupulous contractors operate year-round and target all types of insurance repairs — not just storm damage. Here are the most common warning signs.
- Asks you to sign an Assignment of Benefits (AOB) — this hands them rights under your insurance policy (see below)
- Offers to waive or absorb your deductible — in Texas, for example, it is illegal for a contractor or roofer to offer to waive a deductible on a property-insurance claim without the insurer's consent (Texas Department of Insurance; H.B. 2102, 86th Legislature); ask your insurer or your state's department of insurance how your state treats this
- Demands a large upfront cash payment before any work begins (the Federal Trade Commission lists being asked to pay for everything up front or to pay only in cash among the signs of a home improvement scam)
- Pressures you to sign immediately or claims the offer expires today (the FTC also lists pressure for an immediate decision as a sign of a scam)
- Cannot provide a physical business address (PO Boxes don't count)
- Refuses to pull required permits or tells you permits aren't necessary
- Quotes by the job only, with no itemized breakdown of labor and materials
Assignment of Benefits
AOB arrangements are worth understanding in detail because they are presented by some contractors as a convenience — "so you don't have to deal with the insurer." In practice, signing an AOB hands the contractor rights under your insurance policy. If you are handed one, do not sign it on the spot: read it closely and ask the contractor exactly what it lets them do.
Whether an AOB is allowed depends on your state and your policy. For example, Florida law says a policyholder may not assign post-loss benefits under a residential property insurance policy issued on or after January 1, 2023, with limited exceptions, and that an attempt to do so is void (Florida Statutes section 627.7152(13)). Wherever you live, consult with your insurer and possibly an attorney before signing any AOB.
Deductible Waivers
Your deductible is the part of a covered loss that your policy leaves you to pay. The Texas Department of Insurance calls an offer to waive or absorb it a selling point that bad contractors often use: "The contractor then cuts corners, uses lower quality products, or inflates the bill sent to the insurance company to cover the difference." In Texas it is illegal for a contractor or roofer to offer to waive a deductible on a property-insurance claim without the insurer's consent (Texas Department of Insurance; H.B. 2102, 86th Legislature). Ask your insurer or your state's department of insurance how your state treats a waived deductible.
Permit Avoidance
Ask whether the job needs a permit and who pulls it; your city or county building department can tell you (the Indiana Attorney General advises contacting your local building department to see if a permit is needed, and says a contractor should not start work until the permit is issued). Permits mean the work is inspected to code. A contractor who won't pull a permit the job needs may be unlicensed, cutting scope on the work, or avoiding an inspection. Unpermitted work can complicate future sales of your home.
4. Questions to Ask Before You Hire
A well-qualified contractor will answer these questions readily and specifically. Evasiveness or impatience with credential questions is itself meaningful information.
"Can I have your license number and the name of your insurer?"
This is the first filter. Any legitimate contractor will hand these over without hesitation. A contractor who hedges, provides a license number for a different jurisdiction, or says they're "in the process of renewing" is telling you something important.
"Who will actually be doing the work — your employees or subcontractors?"
Many general contractors use subcontractors, which is normal. But if the job is subcontracted, confirm that the subcontractors are also licensed and insured. Ask for their license and COI as well, or ask the GC to confirm in writing that all subs are covered under the GC's policy.
"Have you done similar work in this area recently? Can you provide local references?"
Ask for three local references from comparable jobs — similar scope, similar construction type — completed within the last 12 months. Call the references. Ask them: Did the project finish on schedule? Did final costs match the estimate? Were there any inspection issues? Would you hire them again?
"Who pulls the permits, and will I receive copies of the inspection sign-offs?"
The contractor should pull the permits — not you. And you should receive paper or digital copies of all passed inspections before making final payment. This protects you if issues arise later.
"What is your payment schedule, and do you require a deposit?"
Ask for the deposit amount and the payment schedule in writing in the contract, with progress payments tied to completion milestones, and a final payment held until work is complete and passes inspection (the FTC says not to pay the full amount for the project up front and to never make the final payment until the work is done and you are satisfied with it). Be wary of contractors who demand a large share of the price upfront, or who want full payment before work begins.
"What warranty do you provide on your workmanship, and do materials carry a manufacturer's warranty?"
Workmanship warranty lengths differ by contractor and trade. Get the warranty terms in writing in the contract — not just in the sales conversation. Understand the difference between the contractor's workmanship warranty and the manufacturer's material warranty, and confirm both are transferable if you sell the property.
"Have you worked on insurance repair jobs before, and are you familiar with my insurer's scope-of-loss format?"
Experience with insurance repair work specifically matters. Contractors who routinely work with insurance claims understand how to document scope, communicate with adjusters, and handle supplement requests if hidden damage is found once work begins.
5. Getting and Comparing Quotes
Before you collect a single bid, find out whether your policy pays on an actual cash value (ACV) basis or a replacement cost value (RCV) basis. The two call for different strategies. Your declarations page says which one you have, and if your policy has a separate roof endorsement, check that too. Our ACV vs. RCV guide shows where to look.
If You Have an ACV Policy: Price Is the Whole Game
On an ACV policy, the first check from your insurer is most likely all the insurance money you are going to get. There is no second payment waiting for you, so every dollar a contractor saves you is a dollar that stays in your pocket. On an ACV policy the insurer does not require you to spend the check on the roof, so it is your decision. Two cautions: if you have a mortgage, your lender's name is probably on the check and the servicer may control how it is released; and if you leave the damage unrepaired, a later claim for that same damage may be denied or reduced. Check with your servicer and your insurer before you spend it.
Send every contractor the same scope of work
Give each contractor the scope of work from your insurance estimate. When everyone prices the same list of work, the bids are apples to apples, and the gaps between them mean something. If one bid leaves out work the others include, you will see it right away.
Ask subcontractors as well as general contractors
A general contractor often sells the job and hires a crew to do the work. The subcontractor is that crew. Ask for bids from both, and compare. The difference between the two is what working directly with the sub could save you.
Compare materials line by line
A low bid with builder-grade shingles and a high bid with a top-tier shingle are not the same product. Get every bid in writing and itemized, with the shingle line and product name, the underlayment, ventilation, flashing, haul-away and permit costs. A one-line bid such as "Roof replacement, $12,000" cannot be compared to anything. Our roof bid comparison worksheet lines the bids up side by side.
If You Have an RCV Policy: Compete on Materials and Warranties
Most RCV policies pay in two steps. The insurer first pays the actual cash value of the damaged roof, which is the replacement cost minus depreciation. It holds back the depreciation, called recoverable depreciation, and releases it after the work is finished and you send in proof, usually the contractor's invoice and photos. Policies differ on the paperwork and the deadline, so read the claim settlement section of yours. Our guide to recoverable depreciation has the example math.
Here is what that means for shopping. Once the work is done and documented, your out-of-pocket cost is your deductible, plus any depreciation your policy does not recover, and a contractor cannot cover the deductible for you. To waive or cover your deductible, a contractor usually has to bill your insurer for more than you actually pay. Knowingly overstating the cost of a job to an insurer can be insurance fraud, for the homeowner who submits the bill as well as the contractor.
Indiana, Texas and Florida each have a law aimed at a contractor who offers to pay, waive or rebate a deductible (see the statutes in Sources). A contractor who offers to is a red flag, so walk away. With the deductible fixed and the bid matching the work in your insurance estimate, the lowest price is not where you win. You win on the package: the materials and the warranties.
Pick three contractors you would trust to do your roof
Check each one's license, insurance and local references first (the credential and license checks earlier in this guide). You are choosing three you would be glad to hire, then making them compete on what goes on the roof and what stands behind it.
Ask the first contractor for their best package
Use the target package below. Ask for it in writing, with the product names and the warranty names, not just "premium shingles."
Take that package to the other two
Hand them the written package and ask whether they will beat it. Contractors who know they are competing for the job are more likely to add materials and warranties to win it. Then go back to the first contractor with the best of what you found.
The Target Package
Whichever policy you have, these are the differences between roofing bids that change how your roof performs. Ask every contractor for each one by name.
- The top wind warranty for that shingle: (see wind ratings explained) Manufacturers sell wind coverage in levels, and the top level depends on how the roof is installed. For example, GAF Timberline shingles carry a 110 mph rating with four nails, 130 mph with GAF starter strips added, and no maximum wind speed under the WindProven warranty when four required GAF accessories are used. Owens Corning lists limited wind coverage up to 160 mph on Duration shingles when its components are used and starter shingles are installed on the eaves and rakes, and CertainTeed offers a wind warranty upgrade to 160 mph on Landmark PRO. The base level is usually 110 mph. Ask the contractor which level they are quoting and what installation it requires.
- A Class 4 impact rating (UL 2218): (see Class 4 shingles) Class 4 is the highest rating in the test. Not every architectural shingle has it. Owens Corning Duration is Class 3, while Duration STORM is Class 4, and GAF's Timberline AS II is Class 4. A Class 4 rating is a test result, not a promise that the shingle will resist hail damage, and the manufacturer may not warrant it against hail. Ask your insurance company whether it offers a discount for impact-resistant roofing.
- A 25-year algae warranty: (see algae warranties) Algae streaks are the black stains on a roof. Look for a 25-year algae warranty or better, and ask what it requires. GAF's 25-year StainGuard Plus covers only shingles sold in packages marked StainGuard Plus, and Owens Corning's 25-year StreakGuard warranty requires an Owens Corning hip and ridge product.
- A manufacturer-backed labor warranty: (see manufacturer-backed warranties) Many roof leaks trace back to the installation, not the shingle. A contractor's own workmanship warranty is only as good as the contractor. Manufacturers such as GAF offer system warranties that cover the labor, but only when a certified installer registers a full system. Ask which warranty tier the contractor is registering, whether they hold the certification it requires, and who files the registration. Get the tier named in the contract.
- A manufacturer defect warranty: This one comes with the shingles. Get the length and terms in writing, and ask whether it is transferable if you sell the house. Our guides to the limited lifetime warranty and warranty tiers explain what is covered.
- The contractor's own workmanship warranty: (see workmanship warranties) Get the length in writing, and ask what it covers and who answers the phone in year five.
A top-tier manufacturer labor and defects warranty is usually the strongest warranty you can get on a shingle roof, for several reasons. First, the manufacturer, not only the contractor, stands behind the installation work, typically for 25 years or more. Second, the roof must be installed by a contractor the manufacturer has accepted into its own top installer program, which typically requires licensing where the state requires it, insurance, trained crews and a track record with the brand. Finally, they typically list a long period in which material defects are covered without a reduction for age.
Published terms from three manufacturers show the pattern. For an individually owned single-family detached home, GAF Golden Pledge lists 25 or 30 years of non-prorated workmanship coverage, depending on the shingle, and a 50-year non-prorated material-defect period (shorter terms apply to other properties), and only a GAF Master Elite contractor can install it; GAF also offers a President's Club warranty, with 40 years of non-prorated workmanship coverage, through a smaller group of its Master Elite contractors. Owens Corning Platinum Protection lists 25 years of workmanship coverage before any reduction for a single-family detached home, and a 50-year material-defect period without a reduction for age on its lifetime shingles (20 years for other structures), and it requires an Owens Corning Platinum Preferred Contractor. CertainTeed's 5-Star extended warranty, offered through its SELECT ShingleMaster contractors, has CertainTeed cover the contractor's workmanship for 25 years.
Algae causes the dark streaks on your roof that make your roof look old. Shingle manufacturers fight algae by adding copper to the granules on the shingle surface. Over time, that copper leaches out as rain washes over the roof, and the shingles lose their algae protection. Most algae-resistant shingles have an algae warranty of at least 10 years, but in the last few years those warranties have grown to 25 or 30 years on higher grade shingles. Algae warranties depend on the brand and line of shingle you use.
Some shingles earn a longer algae warranty by releasing copper over a longer period, through more copper, a time-release design, or both, and some brands also require their matching ridge cap shingles for the longer term. So if you want a longer algae warranty, choose a shingle line that carries one, and check whether the brand's ridge cap shingles are required to get it. Finally, if you want to be a true roofing nerd about this topic, you can tell people that the black streaks aren't true algae at all. They're a bacterium, a cyanobacterium called Gloeocapsa magma. But we say algae because everyone knows what algae is.
Read Your Bids Against the Insurer's Estimate
Compare each bid with the scope of work in your insurance estimate. If a bid includes work that is not in the estimate, ask the contractor to mark it as a separate line so you can see the price. How that work relates to your claim is a question for your insurer and your policy. Our guide to a bid that is higher than the insurance estimate covers how to compare the two documents.
Check the Payment Terms Too
If you have a mortgage, the insurance check is generally made out to you and your mortgage servicer, and the servicer may release the money in stages. Ask each contractor whether the payment schedule in the bid can follow your servicer's schedule. Our guide on paying a contractor when the check names your mortgage company has the questions to ask.
Otter Quotes and Competitive Bids
Otter Quotes takes the legwork out of this. You provide a copy of your insurance estimate, we create a written scope of work and send it to multiple contractors, and they compete online with bids on the same work. You compare the bids side by side, next to reviews and licensing information, without a salesperson in your home. See how it works for the full process.
6. Reviewing the Contract Before You Sign
A contractor's proposal is not a contract until it's a signed, written agreement with specific terms. Here's what every insurance repair contract should contain — and what to refuse to sign. State consumer offices publish similar lists. The Indiana Attorney General lists the price, a payment schedule, a detailed description of the work and materials, and estimated start and completion dates; the Ohio Attorney General lists a provision requiring written approval for any changes.
What the Contract Must Include
- Full legal name and license number of the contracting entity
- Physical business address and contact information
- Detailed scope of work — materials, grade, quantity, and labor tasks, not vague summaries
- Estimated start date and substantial completion date, with provisions for delay
- Payment schedule tied to project milestones, not arbitrary dates
- Who is responsible for pulling permits
- Workmanship warranty terms in writing
- Dispute resolution process (arbitration clause terms, if any)
- Change order procedure — any scope changes must be in writing before work proceeds
What to Refuse to Sign
- Assigns your insurance benefits to the contractor (Assignment of Benefits / AOB)
- Authorizes the contractor to negotiate your claim directly with your insurer without your involvement
- Waives your right to dispute the final invoice
- Includes a clause where you accept that permits "are not required" for the described scope — verify this independently
- Has blank spaces in any material term — price, scope, dates
Change Orders
Hidden damage discovered once work begins is common in insurance repair jobs — water damage behind walls, rotten decking under shingles, deteriorated framing behind stucco. Legitimate contractors document discovered damage with photographs, provide a written change order describing the additional scope and cost, and wait for your signature before proceeding. Never allow a contractor to proceed with additional work based on a verbal agreement alone.
7. How Otter Quotes Helps You Choose
Otter Quotes is a bid platform designed specifically for homeowners navigating property damage and insurance repair projects. The process is straightforward: you describe your project and upload your adjuster's estimate, and we put it in front of contractors who serve your area to submit competitive written bids.
This solves the most common friction points in contractor selection:
- Multiple written bids, fast: Instead of calling contractors one by one and waiting for callbacks, you get competitive bids in one place without the scheduling overhead
- Adjuster estimate alignment: You can share your adjuster's scope with bidding contractors directly, so bids come back against the same scope — making comparisons meaningful
- Written, itemized proposals: The platform is built around written bids, not verbal estimates — giving you the documentation you need for both contractor selection and your insurer
Otter Quotes does not make the hiring decision for you — that remains yours. But it gives you the competitive bids and documentation to make that decision on solid footing. Learn more at how it works. If you have questions about a specific bid or want to understand your adjuster's estimate, our FAQ covers common questions in detail.
Ready to Get Competing Bids?
Describe your project and receive written bids from contractors who serve your area and choose to bid — no pressure, no commitment until you choose.
Get Bids on Your ProjectFrequently Asked Questions
How do I verify a contractor's license?
If your state licenses the trade, its contractor licensing board website is the place to look. Search by business name or license number; if there is no state license, ask your city or county building department what applies. The license should be active, match the trade you need, and list the correct business entity. Don't rely on the contractor to provide a screenshot — look it up yourself on the issuing office's official website.
What insurance should a contractor carry?
At minimum, look for general liability insurance and workers' compensation. Request a Certificate of Insurance (COI) and call the insurance company directly to confirm the policy is active and hasn't been cancelled. The phone number should come from the insurer's official website, not the COI itself.
What is an Assignment of Benefits (AOB) and should I sign one?
An Assignment of Benefits (AOB) is a document that hands the contractor rights under your insurance policy. Whether an AOB is allowed, and what it lets the contractor do, depends on your state and your policy. Do not sign one on the spot: read it closely, ask the contractor exactly what it lets them do, and consult your insurer and, if needed, an attorney first.
How many quotes should I get for an insurance repair?
Get at least three written, itemized quotes. Multiple bids help you understand fair market pricing, identify unusually low bids, and give you leverage to negotiate scope gaps with your insurer. All bids should itemize materials, labor, and permit costs — not just a total job price.
Can my insurer tell me which contractor to use?
That depends on your policy and your state. Your insurer may have a preferred contractor network. Check your policy documents for any provisions about choosing a contractor, and ask your state's department of insurance if you are unsure of your options. If you choose your own contractor, ensure their bid aligns with your adjuster's scope before work begins to avoid payment disputes.
What are warning signs of a dishonest contractor?
Key red flags include: pressure to sign immediately, requests for large upfront cash payments, no physical business address, inability to provide verifiable credentials, asking you to sign an AOB, promising to waive or absorb your deductible, quoting a total price with no itemized breakdown, and unwillingness to pull permits. Any single one of these warrants caution; multiple red flags together should cause you to walk away.
What should I do if a contractor finds additional damage during the repair?
Ask the contractor to stop work, document the discovered damage with photographs, and contact your insurer before authorizing any additional scope. Ask your insurer how to submit a supplement request for the additional damage. Never authorize additional work based on a verbal agreement — require a written change order with documented scope and pricing before work resumes.
Sources
- Texas Department of Insurance, State Law Cracks Down on Roof Scams: it is illegal for contractors or roofers to offer to waive a deductible or promise a rebate for all or part of a deductible; describes contractors who cut corners, use lower quality products or inflate the bill to cover the difference.
- Indiana Code section 24-5-11-10.5 (2025 Indiana Code, via Justia): a real property improvement supplier may not advertise, offer or promise to pay or rebate any part of an insurance deductible to induce a person to enter into a contract or buy goods or services.
- Florida Statutes section 489.147(2)(b): a contractor may not offer a residential property owner a waiver of any insurance deductible in exchange for allowing a roof inspection or making an insurance claim for roof damage.
- Texas H.B. 2102, 86th Legislature: makes it an offense for a seller to waive, absorb or rebate an insured's deductible without the insurer's consent.
- Florida Statutes section 627.7152: for residential and commercial property insurance policies issued on or after January 1, 2023, and except as subsection (11) provides, an attempt to assign post-loss property insurance benefits is void, invalid and unenforceable (subsection 13).
- Federal Trade Commission, How To Avoid a Home Improvement Scam: scammers ask you to pay up front or only in cash and pressure you for an immediate decision; do not pay the full amount up front; never make the final payment until the work is done and you are satisfied.
- National Roofing Contractors Association, Selecting a Contractor: ask for copies of the contractor's liability insurance coverage and workers' compensation certificates; insist on a written proposal with complete descriptions of the work and specifications.
- Office of the Indiana Attorney General, Protect yourself from Storm Chaser Scams: a home improvement contract should include the price, payment schedule, a detailed description of the work and materials and estimated start and completion dates; contact your local building department to see if a permit is needed (an example of one state's guidance).
- Ohio Attorney General, Consumer Tips: Home Improvement: a contract should include a provision requiring written approval for any changes and a requirement for the contractor to obtain all necessary permits and inspections (an example of one state's guidance).